
Lenny Pappano – Giants 24, Patriots 20
My take on Super Bowl XLVI. The keys will be:
1. The Giants defensive front four vs. the Patriots O-line. The Giants can get pressure on Brady and stop the run with just 4 guys. That’s a marked advantage in stopping the Pats offense.
2. Rob Gronkowski’s ankle. Gronk’s dad said his son is suffering from a high-ankle sprain. If he isn’t effective, it could be a huge drawback for the Pats – especially inside the red zone.
3. Pats secondary vs. Giants WRs. Mario Manningham has already said he hopes Pats WR/emergency CB Julian Edelman gets matched up against him. Edelman got torched by Ravens WR Anquan Boldin in the AFC title game.
4. Bill Belichick is a genius who can out-think, out-maneuver and even out-cheat the best of ‘em. And Tom Brady is Tom Brady. Those two might be enough to neutralize the advantages I think the Giants have on paper. But…
Prediction: Giants 24-Pats 20
Jared Smola – Patriots 31, Giants 27
There are some intriguing storylines surrounding this game: the Patriots avenging their Super Bowl 42 loss, Brady going for his 4th ring, Eli going for his 2nd in the house Peyton built. None of it will mean jack squat when the ball is kicked off on Sunday.
This game – as they all do – will come down to the players on the field and the coaches on the sidelines. The Giants have the edge in the overall talent department. They have a better pass-rush, a deeper WR corps, and the more productive ground game. New York’s trio of Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz, and Mario Manningham will give the Patriots’ secondary fits. And RBs Ahmad Bradshaw and Brandon Jacobs should be able to get rolling against a defense that’s allowed 4.3 yards per carry to RBs this year.
But New England has the advantage in 2 key areas: coaching and QB play.
There isn’t a better Xs and Os coach in the league than Bill Belichick. Give him 2 weeks to prepare and he’ll come up with a brilliant game plan. In fact, the Patriots are 9-3 coming off a bye week under Belichick, and 3-1 in the Super Bowl. That’s a .750 winning percentage with an extra week to scheme. Belichick will put his guys in a position to succeed on Sunday.
But as NFL games usually do, this one will hinge on QB play. As impressive as Eli Manning has been this season –especially in the 4th quarter – I still have more faith in Tom Brady with the game on the line. He’s orchestrated 34 career game-winning drives, with 3 of those coming in the Super Bowl. Brady struggled against the Ravens last week, which is only another reason to believe he’ll bring his “A” game this Sunday.
New York’s best chance to slow Brady down will be with their 4-man pass-rush. But New England’s offensive line is playing its best ball of the year. They’ve allowed just 1 sack over the past 2 games. And those have come against the Broncos and Ravens, who ranked 11th and 3rd, respectively, in sacks during the regular season. If Brady gets ample time in the pocket, he’ll pick a mediocre Giants secondary apart.
I expect this game to come down to the final few minutes. And I expect Brady to get it done with a late TD. 31-27 Patriots.
Matt Schauf – Giants 24, Patriots 17
We all just watched the Patriots shrug off a Ravens pass rush that tied the Giants for 3rd in the league in sacks this season. Some might expect a similar result this Sunday. Don’t.
Pass rushing isn’t just about sacks. It’s also about disrupting the QB. To that end, the Giants have produced 50 more total pressures (sacks/hits/pressures) than Baltimore in just 1 more game this year. The numbers come from ProFootballFocus.com and have been near ridiculous in the playoffs. The NFC title game brought a season-high 20 pressures to go with 5 sacks and 2 hits. The week before saw 4 sacks of Aaron Rodgers. Credit some of that to DE Osi Umenyiora, who has secretly had an awesome year. The veteran notched 9 sacks in 9 regular-season games despite missing time with 2 separate injuries. He has officially added 3.5 more in the playoffs. The group will give Tom Brady trouble.
On top of that, only 2 Patriots offensive players had impactful games against the Giants in Week 9. Wes Welker figures to get his again. Rob Gronkowski appears likely to don a Willis Reed jersey.
New England preyed on New York’s LBs in coverage late in the last meeting. Even if the Pats can do that again, I don’t see it claiming enough yardage to win this game.
Kevin English – Patriots 27, Giants 24
This game is all about revenge. Not only did New England lose to the Giants in Super Bowl XLII, but they dropped a Week 9 meeting with them this season, 24-20.
Of course, a lot has changed since then. The Pats have rattled off 10 straight Ws, with their last taste of defeat coming at the hands of New York. The Giants ride into this game red hot too, racking up 5 straight victories after losing 5 of 6 over Weeks 10-15.
But with an offensive showcase likely in store, I can’t help but take my chances with Brady over Manning. Not only does he have a superior resume, but he also enjoyed a more impressive 2011, posting 5K yards for the first time, while tossing the second most TDs of his career. And you know he’ll be looking to prove last week’s dud against Baltimore (239 yards, 2INTs) was a fluke.
Rob Gronkowski’s injury is obviously a cause for concern, but if you’ve seen the guy play, you know he’s a superhuman athlete. Even if he’s only 80-85%, Gronk’s still more dangerous than most starting TEs in the NFL.
Not to venture too far off the beaten path… but I see this game coming down to the final drive. I think the Pats D brings their “A” game – as they have over the last 2 weeks – to secure a victory.
Jim Coventry – Patriots 34, Giants 31
This one’s gonna be a classic, at least for those who like to see plenty of offense. The Patriots will show off the best ‘horizontal’ passing attack in the league, which matches up very well against the Giants’ zone defense and should slow down their red-hot pass rush. The Giants, on the other hand, boast a dynamic set of skill position players in a potent passing attack that is facing the 2nd-worst pass defense in NFL history. Although this could easily be a game that is won by the last team with the ball, the Patriots will have enough to win this rematch of Super Bowl XLII teams.
The Giants have struggled against TEs and slot receivers all season, and the Patriots will use Wes Welker, (a likely limited) Rob Gronkowski, and Aaron Hernandez to expose the major weakness of the New York defense. When these teams met earlier in the season, all three of these New England weapons had big games, and they should be able to do even better on the big stage of the Super Bowl. The Patriots ultimately lost that regular season game, as they took far too many shots downfield. Expect HC Bill Belichick to learn from that game and allow to Brady to pick apart the defense with short to intermediate passes.
Although the Patriots had a historically bad pass defense this year (2nd worst all-time), they seem to be peaking at the right time. The Giants still figure to be able to move the ball up and down the field, but the Pats are due to take advantage when Eli Manning makes a mistake. In the last two meetings between these teams, Manning led game-winning drives at the end of the game. What many people tend to forget is that Eli threw easy INTs on both of those big drives that were inexplicably dropped by the defender. The New England defense was 2nd in the league with 23 INTs and won’t let Manning off the hook this time around.
Tom Brady tends to ratchet up his game to another level when he feels challenged, and he’s not about to let Manning and the Giants put another dent in his legacy. Brady will hoist another MVP trophy after looking at the scoreboard and seeing Patriots 34, Giants 31.
www.draftsharks.com