by Kevin English
You’ve seen it before. And there’s a good chance you’ll be seeing it again.
I’m talking about someone in your fantasy football draft who selects a team defense early. Really early. Say, 8th round early.
That’s the current ADP of the Jets D – 8.06. Absurd, right?
Of course. But that won’t stop an off-their-rocker league-mate from investing a mid-round pick in them. If by chance you fall into that category, please, continue reading – it just might save your fantasy football career.
First off, I see the appeal in Gang Green’s defense. They have an excellent tandem at CB with Darrelle Revis and Antonio Cromartie. They’ve got ideal 3-4 ‘backers in Bart Scott, Byran Thomas, David Harris, Calvin Pace, and free agent acquisition Jason Taylor. On the line, they’ll welcome back DT Kris Jenkins, a dominant run stuffer that missed 10 games due to injury last year. That’s all fine and dandy. But simply put, their crew of house-hold names aren’t going to produce the fantasy totals many are expecting.
Let’s take a look at why by examining their 2009 performance.
Last year, the Jets defense was downright stingy. They ranked 1st against the pass, 8th against the run, and allowed a mere 14.8 points per game – tops in the league. Hell, they allowed just 8 passing TDs all season; outside of the Jets, no team surrendered fewer than 14. Surely, they finished in the top-5, if not top-3, among team defenses in fantasy leagues. No? Top-10? It might come as a surprise, but the Jets defense didn’t finish the ’09 season higher than 10th in any fantasy format.
What held the Jets back was their inability to get to the QB. They tallied a pedestrian 32 sacks – ranking 21st in the league. The Jets also didn’t record the INTs you’d expect, snagging a middle-of-the-road 17. It might not seem like a huge deal, but those two statistics – two of the biggest when it comes to the success of team defenses in fantasy football – really prevented Rex Ryan’s crew from becoming an elite option.
In 2010, despite a wave of new additions, don’t expect the Jets to crack the top-3 team defenses. And certainly don’t expect them to finish as the far and away #1 D like many do. Let’s briefly go through their major additions – and 2009 holdovers – that have so many fantasy freaks drinking the Kool-Aid.
Jason Taylor: JT has 127.5 career sacks, and is one of the best pass-rushers of his time. That’s undeniable. Taylor, however, was good – but not great – last year, posting 7 sacks while in a pass-rushing role. He’ll hold a similar role in New York, but the longtime Fin will turn 36 before Week 1, and we’re skeptical he’ll continue to play at his 2009 level. The future Hall of Famer is far from a sure thing.
Antonio Cromartie: After his 10 INT season in 2007, Cromartie has mustered just 5 over the last 2 seasons. He’s battled nagging hip and hammy injuries during that time, both of which re-appeared this offseason. He sat out some OTAs because of the injury, but it’s not severe. Still, it’s a reminder the 26-year-old isn’t 100%, and that expecting a repeat of his ’07 season is a pipe dream.
Kyle Wilson: A rookie from Boise State, Wilson is likely to step into the nickel corner role from day 1. Many touted him as the best CB in the draft, and expect him to perform admirably from day 1. We’re not so sure though. He went relatively untested at BSU, and is likely to need some time to get adjusted to playing at the NFL level. He won’t contribute much to the fantasy success of the Jets defense.
Darrelle Revis: Revis posted 6 INTs last year, tops in his career. But heading into 2010, opposing offenses will be diverting their attention to the opposite side of the field for all 16 games. Revis will remain dominant, but his mark of 6 INTs will drop.
Kris Jenkins: As previously noted, Jenkins will return to the starting lineup after missing substantial time last season. He’s been practicing in minicamps, but it’s anyone’s guess as to how the 350-pounders’ knees will hold up post-ACL surgery. Even if he remains healthy, Jenkins doesn’t hold the key to the Jets fantasy success. He has just 24 career sacks, and hasn’t posted more than 3.5 since 2003.
When all is said and done, there’s a good chance the Jets defense will improve upon their fantasy standing from a year ago. But we’ll hold firm that the Jets, or any other team defense, is not worth a mid-round pick in fantasy drafts. Take your 3rd or 4th RB or WR. Take your starting QB or your starting TE. Take anything but a team defense. And, of course, your kicker.