
by guest writer, Mike Pallaci
One of the many things that has made being a Bills fan for the past decade or two so painful is not just that they lose, but how they lose. I’ve never seen a team find more creative ways to lose games. From baffling coaching decisions, to impossible plays being made by the opposition, to complete 4th quarter boneheadedness on the part of their own players, the Bills are the masters of the soul-sucking loss. My friends and I joked one day that if there was an ESPY for the Most Creative Way to Lose a Game, or for the Most Soul-Sucking Loss, the Bills would not only win the award, they would probably secure all of the nominations. I tried to narrow it down to 10, but I couldn’t. Ever hear of a Baker’s Dozen? Here’s a Bills Fan’s Top 10 Nominees for the ESPY for Most Inexplicable Loss:
1.) 2008: Playing a “home game” in Toronto, where the fans are heard on national TV chanting “Let’s go Dolphins,” the game is on the line and JP Losman, the Bills’ turnover machine of a backup QB, is in the game. The Bills face a 1st and goal at the 3 yard line, so they call a corner fade pass (because at this point in the game, Marshawn Lynch is only averaging 8 yards per carry). The pass is naturally intercepted, ending any realistic hopes of a playoff spot.
2.) 2008: In a game in which their star running back is gashing the Jets defense for over 6 yards per carry, the Bills take the ball with four and a half minutes to go and a 3 point lead. Despite the Jets playing a 9-man front, Lynch runs for 4, 5, 3, and 5 yards on the first four plays of the drive, and they have a 2nd and 5 with 2:05 left. So with the running game rolling, they make the obvious play call – they drop the aforementioned turnover factory of a backup QB back for a pass, he does his trademark hold it too long routine, rolls to his right, is stripped from behind, and the fumble is recovered and returned for the game-winning TD. Milestone: the first time I have sworn at the TV during a Bills game in front of my son.
3.) 2007: Playing in front of the loudest Buffalo crowd in years while I’m stuck at work on a Monday night, the 1-3 Bills injury-ravaged defense, playing without roughly half of its starters, forces the 4-0 Cowboys into 6 turnovers and leads by 8 with 3:45 left. Game over. But wait – Tony Romo and his 5 INTs leads the Cowboys down the field for a TD with 36 seconds left. The two-point conversion attempt is slapped away from All-World WR Terrell Owens by 4th string CB Jabari Greer – game over. But wait – the Cowboys recover the onside kick. But wait – the replay shows the Cowboys touched it before 10 yards. Game over. But wait – the call is somehow upheld on review. With no timeouts left, Romo completes a long pass to TO. But wait – he was out of bounds, it is reversed. 13 seconds left, no timeouts. Game over. But wait – the Bills inexplicably give up two easy passes to the sideline (how do you not defend the sideline when they have no timeouts and only 13 seconds left on the clock???) and the Cowboys have the ball at the Bills’ 35. Nick Folk kicks a game-winning 53 yard field goal – game over. But wait – the Bills called timeout before the snap. Game over. He can’t possibly kick a game-winning 53 yard field goal twice in a row – he sucks, it’s a miracle he made it once. But wait – the f%$er makes it again. Game over – for real this time. I leave the doctors lounge at work, kick the Cowboy fan tech in the groin, punch my nurse in the face, walk into my next patient’s room and say “What the hell do YOU want?”
4.) 2000: After a hard fought road playoff game, the Bills celebrate after Rob Johnson, making his second start of the year, leads them on a drive for a game winning FG after starting the drive with no timeouts and 1:47 left. With just seconds to go, the Bills kick off, scrub FB Lorenzo Neal picks up the squib and hands to Frank Wycheck, who throws – FORWARD – to Kevin Dyson, who runs down the sideline for the winning TD. Referee Phil Luckett, who became the first official in recorded history to screw up a coin toss on Thanksgiving in Detroit the year before, somehow looks at the replay and fails to see what everybody else did – that the ball was thrown forward – so the play stands, and the Bills are eliminated. The Titans go on to the Super Bowl; the Bills haven’t been back to the playoffs since.
5.) 2007: In a game where the Bills have lost their starting FS for the year with a broken leg, their starting CB for the year with a broken forearm, their fill-in starting LB and best special teams player for 6 weeks with a sprained knee, and their #2 TE and special teams stud forever with a broken neck, they somehow lead Denver by 2 as first-year starter Jay Cutler takes the ball with 2:13 left. After converting two 4th downs on the drive, Cutler completes a pass that puts Denver in field goal range with 14 seconds left. With no timeouts left, the offense sprints off the field, the field goal team sprints on (a play that every team in the NFL practices and says takes 16 seconds if done perfectly), and miraculously gets the ball snapped before time expires, kicking the game winning field goal. My 7-year-old son goes up to his room, lays in bed and cries. Another milestone: the first time I felt like a bad father for raising my son to be a fan of this team.
6.) 2004: The Bills have high hopes for the season as they open at home against Jacksonville. The defense has been stifling all day, and they lead 10-6 as Jacksonville takes the ball with 2:16 left and one time out. On 4th and 14, Byron Leftwich heaves a desperation pass down the sideline for Jimmy Smith, who is covered like a blanket by the self-proclaimed Playmaker, Nate Clements. Rather than bat the ball down and secure the victory, The Playmaker tries to pad his stat sheet and secure a spot on ESPN NFL Primetime by going for the interception. The ball goes through his hands and into Smith’s for a first down and a 45-yard catch. After converting another 4th down, the Jags have 1st and goal from the Bills 7. After three incompletions, they line up for one more play with just seconds to go. With no time left on the clock, Leftwich hurls a desperation pass towards the back of the endzone in the direction of a receiver nobody has ever heard of before (Ernest Wilford), who despite being triple-covered, hauls in his first catch of the game for the winning score.
7.) 1989: Trailing 34-30 with time running out in a wild card playoff game in Cleveland, Jim Kelly leads the Bills on a drive that is giving Cleveland fans John Elway flashbacks. On 3rd down, Kelly passes for Ronnie Harmon in the endzone, who lets the winning TD go right through his hands. On 4th down, Kelly can’t find anybody open, scrambles, and throws a desperation pass towards the goal line, which is intercepted by Clay Matthews. Game over. Harmon, in post-game interviews, says the ball was overthrown. SI’s cover the following week shows his hands cradling the ball right before he dropped it. Harmon never plays for the Bills again, leaves for San Diego, and becomes one of the best pass-catching RBs in the league.
8.) 2004: The Bills need a little bit of help, but after winning 6 straight games to overcome an 0-4 and 1-5 start, a win over the Steelers at home will probably put them in the playoffs as one of the hottest teams in the league. The Steelers have nothing to play for – their playoff seed is secured regardless of the outcome, so they’re playing their 2nd and 3rd stringers for most of the game. They start 2nd string QB Tommy Maddux, who plays about 2 1/2 quarters. Then they bring in 3rd stringer Brian St. Pierre, who was just activated from the practice squad 2 days before the game. St. Pierre and the Steelers call one pass (an incompletion) the rest of the way. #1 RB Jerome Bettis sits. #2 RB Duce Staley plays the first quarter, the #3 RB plays half of the 2nd quarter, then gives way to #4 RB Willie Parker, an undrafted rookie free agent, who proceeds to gash the Bills for 102 yards in the last 2 1/2 quarters without the threat of a passing game. Somehow the Bills starters are trailing the Steelers’ no-names by 2 in the 4th quarter, but they’re driving when Drew Bledsoe fumbles, and James Harrison returns it for a TD. Buffalo gets one more TD, but can’t recover the onside kick, and the Pittsburgh Busboys and Trash Collectors win. To add insult to injury, the help that they needed (the Jets and somebody else losing) happens. A win would have put them in the playoffs. Of course, they haven’t been to the playoffs since.
9.) 1998: The Bills lead the Patriots by 4, but the Pats are driving in the game’s closing minutes. On 4th down, the Pats’ Drew Bledsoe passes to Shawn Jefferson, who catches the ball out of bounds right around midfield with a few seconds left. The referees meet to talk it over, and without realizing his mike is on, referee Jeff Triplett is heard saying “Just give it to ‘em.” They do. There’s time enough left for one more play. Bledsoe fires a Hail Mary to the endzone, and Henry Jones knocks it away from Terry Glenn. The Bills celebrate – except there’s a flag on the field. They called pass interference. In the endzone. On a Hail Mary. The replay, of course, doesn’t even show contact, let alone pass interference. In 30 years of watching football, it is still the only PI call I’ve ever seen on a Hail Mary to end a game. One untimed down from the 1, which Bledsoe completes to Ben Coates for the winning TD. The Bills leave the field in disgust, and refuse to come out for the PAT, so Adam Vinatieri runs it in for the 2-point conversion and 4 point win. Ralph Wilson, one of the most mild-mannered and classiest owners in sports, is fined $50,000 by the league for his post-game comments lambasting the officials.
10.) 2009: After an offseason that started optimistically with the signing of Terrell Owens, then devolved into chaos when they traded All-Pro LT Jason Peters when they couldn’t sign him, followed by a 3-game suspension of All-Pro RB Marshawn Lynch, then by the firing of their offensive coordinator 10 days before the opener, then by the release of their new starting LT 6 days before the season, leaving them with a first-time OC and one starter on the O-line who started last year (at a different position than this year), and a starting LT who has never taken a snap in the NFL, the Bills open as a hopeless 13-point underdog at New England on Monday night. Inexplicably, the have a 24-13 lead (against a team that has beaten them 11 straight times) with 5 minutes to go. My brother texts me with “Oh my God…” which makes me want to drive 40 minutes to his house and cut his throat (Has he no appreciation of history? Does he not know that he just guaranteed we would find a way to give it away now?) The Pats get the ball, and score with 2:06 left. The Pats still have all three timeouts left, so they kick deep against the Bills hands team, and Leodis McKelvin runs the ball out of the endzone to try and run the clock past the two minute warning – a reasonable play, except he fumbles while fighting for extra yardage at the end of the return (not a reasonable play) and the Pats recover. Brady promptly puts the Pats in the endzone again, giving the Pats the lead and the eventual victory, sucking the soul out of me again. To add to the joy of the opener, the Bills lose starting MLB Paul Posluszny for at least a month to a broken arm (the second time in his three years in the NFL that he has broken his left arm in Foxboro in September) and starting DE Chris Kelsay to a knee injury.
11.) 2009: The 1-3 Bills and 0-4 Browns are locked in one of the worst football games ever seen. The combination of windy conditions and two awful football teams is painful to endure. The game is so bad that owner Ralph Wilson cancels the planned halftime ceremony to get his Hall of Fame ring for fear of being booed. The Bills started the game without their two starting safeties and their starting MLB, then lost two more LBs to injury during the game, leaving them with two players who weren’t taken in the NFL draft at the OLB positions and their worst starting OLB in the middle. The Bills commit 15 penalties, 13 of which are accepted, including 9 false starts (9 FALSE STARTS!! AT HOME!!!), 2 personal fouls and an offsides. All six offensive linemen who played were flagged at least once, most of them twice. The Browns somehow find themselves tied at 3 late in the fourth quarter despite having a QB who is 2-17 (11.8%) for 23 yards and one interception for a robust 15.4 QB rating. Yes, that’s an NFL QB that is 2-17 for 23 yards late in the 4th quarter – and is tied. They drop back to punt with about 2:30 left, and Roscoe Parrish, who has already ran backwards 15 yards on a previous punt return, tries to pick up a rolling ball off the turf, muffs it, and Cleveland recovers. Cleveland kills clock and kicks the game-winning field goal with 26 seconds left. They proceed to try and give the game back to the Bills by kicking the ensuing kickoff out of bounds, but the Bills can’t even cross midfield until the last play on their pathetic attempt at the “Cal Band Play.”
All you Bills fans out there can feel free to add your own nominee. We could even make it fun and have a vote. Or we could all commit mass suicide. Either way.